My mom’s cousin from Texas commented on my recent use of molasses: “A staple in every Hoosier’s kitchen!” On that note, I hereby declare a week of molasses recipe-sharing at cozywalls.com. These cookies come by way of my Great-Grandmother’s Sister-in-Law, Aunt Velma. Though I never knew her, I cannot mistake the smell of these cookies baking in the oven: the combination of cloves and molasses warms the soul.

When I was little, my mom would let me roll the dough balls in a bowl of sugar before placing them on the cookie sheet. For this batch I used some pretty big sparkle sugar, and the added crunch and shimmer was a delightful result (don’t be fooled by the crunch though, these cookies are also soft-middled). Usually paired with a glass of milk or mug of tea, this week at the store there was a bargain on black cherry gelato. Together with that blackstrap molasses cookie, the gelato was transformed into a black forest trifle of molasses sorts. I like to think of it as Blackstrap Forest.

Aunt Velma’s Molasses Cookies

Preheat Oven to 375-degrees

Mix together:
3/4 cups shortening
1 cup packed brown sugar
1 egg
1/4 cup molasses
1.5 teaspoons baking soda
1/4 teaspoon salt
1/2 teaspoon cloves
1 teaspoon ginger
1 teaspoon cinnamon
about 2 cups flour

Roll in balls “the size of walnuts” and dip in sugar. Bake 8-10 minutes.

49 responses to “molasses cookies with black cherry gelato”

  1. biscuitsandbobbins Avatar
    biscuitsandbobbins

    Love this post, fantastic photos. (the doily shot is my fave) and l-o-v-e the big sparkle sugar!

    1. Amy Avatar
      Amy

      thanks, BB – those grease proof doilies are handy and pretty between cookies!

  2. storybookapothecary Avatar

    yum! I love Talenti Gelato!

    1. Amy Avatar
      Amy

      favorite flavor?

      1. storybookapothecary Avatar

        a toss up between Blood Orange & Carribean Coconut, you? 🙂

      2. Amy Avatar
        Amy

        I need to taste those! I like Double Dark Chocolate & Mediterranean Mint quite a bit…

      3. storybookapothecary Avatar

        mm sounds goood! Ill have to try those out! lovely photos btw; do you use a macro lens?

      4. Amy Avatar
        Amy

        no macro lens, just the kit lens that came with the camera… Canon T1i.

      5. storybookapothecary Avatar
  3. chefconnie Avatar

    Wow….I mean really wow. Love those cookies and I adore Talgetti Gelato. The strawberry makes me swoon.

    1. Amy Avatar
      Amy

      me too, Chef Connie. I am always ready to taste a new flavor variety!

  4. Aunt Kamie Avatar
    Aunt Kamie

    I made those last week Amy!

    1. Amy Avatar
      Amy

      of course you did 🙂

  5. putneyfarm Avatar

    Great pics and more molasses…we can’t keep up, but we will be making these, too..

  6. mealsfromthemarket Avatar

    Fantastic photos, very artistic! I really enjoy the one looking inside the bowl!

  7. Joann Avatar

    That looks absolutely divine!

    1. Amy Avatar
      Amy

      so much yumminess. I called it a trifle rather than an ice cream sandwich, because I ended up using a spoon to finish the dish 🙂

  8. fleetingdelights Avatar

    This is really pretty! I need to get myself some sparkle sugar now, thanks for the temptation! ❤

    1. Amy Avatar
      Amy

      sparkle sugar is always a good decision 🙂

  9. Margaret Griffin Avatar

    About the best comfort food ever – to the eye and the taste!

  10. Margaret Griffin Avatar

    P.S. The plates under the ice cream sandwich belonged to Amy’s great-grandma on the other side of the family, handed down from her great-grandmother, ca 1824.

    1. Amy Avatar
      Amy

      thanks for the important note, Mom. I love those rosy-hued dishes.

  11. Sibella Avatar

    Wow, these are absolutely gorgeous! 🙂

  12. vintagejenta Avatar
    vintagejenta

    Do you use actual blackstrap molasses or medium or mild molasses in the recipe? You mentioned blackstrap in your post, so I was just curious.

    1. Amy Avatar
      Amy

      Yes, I use blackstrap. Lighter molasses works well too if you prefer.

  13. Willamette Food Adventures Avatar

    Ohhh, I love Talenti! My favorite flavor is Salted Caramel and their sweet reusable containers. These look super yummy.

    1. Amy Avatar
      Amy

      Salted Caramel = on my list! And excellent point – those little containers are fun to reuse.

  14. Jessica Avatar

    I love this opportunity to use cloves! The smell of cloves always bring me back to the 1980’s, cooking with my mom! Thank you, Amy!

  15. Courtney Avatar
    Courtney

    Oh, I just ate a couple of these delicious cookies courtesy of your wonderful mother. She is so, so thoughtful! Bob, my hubby, loved them too! He compared them to his all-time favorite molasses cookies that his grandma used to make. Thanks for sharing! By the way, I’m loving your blog!!

    1. Amy Avatar
      Amy

      Courtney, I am so glad you both enjoyed them 🙂 🙂

  16. chevy49girl Avatar
    chevy49girl

    My Uncle Steve used to send me batches when I was at IU. I looove molasses cookies. I am going to get some big sparkle sugar to use it looks so cool! We always had Brear Rabbit molasses.

    1. Amy Avatar
      Amy

      that’s the kind we used to get too! I am sure that is why I always think of that story with the Tar Baby when I start to pour the molasses in the measuring cup.

  17. zahody Avatar

    Such a great flavour combination!

    1. Amy Avatar
      Amy

      I love it… and now I will be thinking of how to incorporate that combo elsewhere.

  18. candicemdashby Avatar

    *Adds to my to-do list for this weekend, lol.
    I love the addition of back cherry gelato in the middle. How delightful!

      1. Amy Avatar
        Amy

        hope you have a great weekend.

  19. The Scrumptious Pumpkin Avatar

    These cookies are so pretty. Cherry desserts are my husband’s favorite, so I know this dish would be a beg hit at our house 🙂

    1. Amy Avatar
      Amy

      I love cherries too! I hope you enjoy the cookie recipe. I was looking at them the other day thinking, it’s like Christmas in May.

  20. Barrysentials, The He Said She Said Wine blog Avatar

    I love the flavor of blackstrap molasses. I used to make black strap molasses tea when I lived in colder climates like Chicago. Your photos are gorgeous!

    1. Amy Avatar
      Amy

      sounds delicious and comforting – especially during those giant snowfalls!

  21. thecollectiveplate Avatar

    These photos are drool-worthy. Must try this recipe soon – thanks for sharing it! 🙂

    1. Amy Avatar
      Amy

      drool-worthy: I like that seal of approval! you are welcome – hope you enjoy the recipe.

  22. Margaret Griffin Avatar

    And worth mentioning — the sugar-covered dough balls are irresistable to eat before baking!

    1. Amy Avatar
      Amy

      worthy mention.

  23. Jessica Avatar

    Just successfully made these cookies for a Mother’s Day brunch at my parents’ house! It is the perfect level of sweetness, which makes it a terrific pairing with (I’m assuming) just about any type of ice-cream or gelato. We had a choice of either cappucino or chocolate hazelnut gelato this afternoon. Both tasted wonderfully with the cookies! All thanks to you, Amy! And your Aunt Velma, of course! 🙂

    1. Amy Avatar
      Amy

      Jessica, that’s super news! I am going to have to make some more, just to go along with cappuccino gelato – that sounds gooood. I hope that you will enjoy the recipe for years to come 🙂

  24. molasses chocolate cordial kisses | cozywalls Avatar

    […] originally posted my Great Aunt Velma’s molasses cookie recipe* when I made molasses cookies with black cherry gelato. For this test run, I halved the recipe (~32 cookies when you make the dough balls a tablespoon), […]

  25. […] molasses cookies have the perfect amount of sweetness! They were a cinch to make with easily accessible […]

Leave a comment

Nice to see you.

Welcome to cozywalls!

A place I started in the blogging days and recently revived to record and share some of the good stuff.

It’s an archive for inspiration, nostalgia, and gratitude.

©cozywalls

Please share with attribution.

Let’s connect